Famous for his Critics' Choice Television Award-nominated portrayal of Titus Andromedon in the Netflix sitcom Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt, he is also notable for his performances in Broadway productions of Jersey Boys (as Hal Miller); The Little Mermaid (as Sebastian); and Guys and Dolls (as Nicely-Nicely Johnson).
After earning a bachelor's degree in Music from the University of Georgia, he made his first Broadway appearance in the 2005 production of The Beach Boys' musical Good Vibrations.
In 2012, he released a solo music album titled Comfortable.
An only child, he spent his youth in Athens, Georgia, and is openly gay.
He appeared with Tina Fey in four episodes of the popular NBC comedy series 30 Rock.